Pia Toscano Sings All By Myself By Eric Carmen: Video

Pia Toscano killed it on Wednesday night’s episode of American Idol.

Pia Toscano did a song that had been covered by her idol Celine Dion. But it was originally sung …and made famous…by Eric Carmen back in 1975.

What did the judges think of her performance? Jennifer Lopez seemed to approve, “I think a lot of people were wondering what you were going to do to top last week. There it is.” And Randy Jackson said “You have such a natural gift, that, dude, I love it. I’m in awe.”

Check out the vintage video of Eric Carmen and the cover by Pia Toscano.